Daily Archives: January 7, 2012

Typologies of the Drift Rightward Part 1: Outline of Typologies of Marxists, Part 1

I have been reflecting on typologies of rightward shifts among leftists, and so I am writing a few types of rightward shifts from the Marxian left. I am also planning to do the left-liberal and anarchist left shifts right:

  • “Anti-Revisionist who becomes a NGO Democrat”
  1. “Maoist who becomes an elitists trust fund liberal,” example: Bill Ayers 
  2. “Maoist who becomes scared of the enthusiasm of the cultural revolution and becomes a neo-liberal,” example: Most of the French Maoists of the 1970s. 
  • Ex-Trotskyist Neo-liberal
  1. “Trotskyists who get frustrated with ideological purity and start to move either to neo-conservatism,’ examples: Max Shachtman, James Burnham, David Horowitz
  2. “Trotskyists who get frustrated with reactionary leftism and start moving towards more and more neo-liberal positions”  examples: Christopher Hitchens, Brendan O’Neill of Spiked! magazine
  • Western Marxist who gives in to Despair
  1. “Critical Theorists and Western Marxists who cave to the Liberal Ideology,” example: Max Horkheimer 
  2. “Avante-garde cultural Marxists who gives up on the possibility of revolution,” example: Guy Debord, Herbert Marcuse   
  • Marxists who start to engage in believe in rigid typologies and not in the dialectical method
  1. Marxists who drop the method and become teleological “revisionists.” example: Bernstein, Kautsky
  2. Marxists who drop dialectical thinking and move rightward, example: Gregor Lukacs 
  3. Structuralists Marxists who move towards popular right politicians, example: Luccio Colletti 
  • Marxist Social Democrats Who Become Neo-Liberals 
  1. Latin Variety: Daniel Ortega
  2. European Variety: François Mitterrand
  3. American Anti-Communist “Socialists”:  Sidney Hook
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,335 other followers